Best 1911 Holster

Best 1911 Holster in 2020 – Tested and Reviewed

In the world of gun lovers, enthusiasts, the 1911 is a much-respected name. Dating back almost a century, this All-American Classic has gathered a cult following over the years. It is one of the first choices for many gun owners as their go-to concealed carry handguns.

However, all guns require a holster to be used to its fullest potential. Using a low-quality, budget handgun holster with your 1911 will not give you the experience you are looking for. Despite being one of the best weapons on the market, it will feel like crap.

So the first thing you need to do if you own this handgun is to go out and buy the best 1911 holster. However, this task can become extremely confusing and frustrating. Since there are literally thousands of different holsters available these days, even a veteran gun owner can quickly feel overwhelmed.

In this article, we will give you a quick rundown of some of the best 1911 holsters for concealed carry, along with a few helpful tips on how to choose the best out of the bunch. So without any further delay, let us head into the list of products.

Top 7 Best 1911 Holster Reviews

With so many different products available in the market, it can get difficult to find the one that best suits your requirements. If you make the wrong decision when buying, you will end up with a lot of trouble.

A subpar holster will never give you the same performance as an excellent one.Here is a quick roundup of the top 1911 holsters on the market that is worth your strong consideration.

1. Alien Gear Cloak Tuck 3.5 IWB Holster for Concealed Carry

Starting off our list of reviews, we will be looking at a concealed carry holster by the brand Alien Gear Cloak. It comes in a sleek and stylish design that can carry a single firearm discreetly without leaving any visible printing. The size of the unit is perfect for carrying a 1911 handgun without drawing any attention.

It gives you complete freedom on how you want to adjust the right height and cant angle without any extra tools. With the right settings, you can draw your weapon smoothly when you need to in a high-stress situation. Even when it is tucked in under your clothes, drawing your weapon is quick and hassle-free.

Furthermore, the retention adjustment of the device is straightforward and only requires you to turn the screws on the body. The holster is equipped with a small trigger guard to prevent accidental discharge. Besides 1911, it is compatible with a wide range of other firearms, making it highly versatile.

One of its greatest assets is its simple and straightforward design. However, in all its simplicity, it makes no compromise when it comes to durability. It comes with a neoprene backing to help get rid of any discomfort you might feel with an IWB holster that pushes up against your skin.

Pros :

  • Strong and durable construction
  • Comes with a trigger guard
  • The neoprene backing is breathable and sweat-absorbent
  • A lot of customization options


  • Not a great option if you want appendix carry

2. BLACKHAWK SERPA Concealment Holster

Up next, we have another amazing concealed carry holster by the brand Blackhawk. The SERPA comes with many amazing features, but one that stands out the most is its superior auto-lock system. However, one major gripe with the unit is it works better as an open carry holster rather than a concealed one.

The unit comes in a universal size that is compatible with most regular to compact-sized handguns in the market. It has a passive retention system that can be adjusted using the screws on the side of the unit. With this option, you can tighten or loosen the retention until you are satisfied with how it feels quickly.

When holstered, you can get a full grip on your weapon. This feature ensures that you can draw faster and more efficiently, no matter what the situation is. With your purchase, you get both a belt loop and a paddle platform that allows you to carry it however you wish.

 The best feature of the unit is its trademark auto-lock technology. It ensures that when you holster your weapon, it securely locks itself unless you pull it out again. There is an audible click sound that lets you know when the locking system is enabled, and thanks to this feature, the utility of this unit increase tenfold.

Pros :

  • Unique locking system that improves security
  • Adjustable passive retention system
  • Allows you to get a full grip on your weapon
  • Comes with both belt loop and paddle platform


  • Not suitable as a concealed carry holster for its size

3. ComfortTac Ultimate Belly Band Holster for Concealed Carry

If you want concealment but do not want to deal with the discomfort of carrying an IWB holster, a belly band holster might be a great option. And when it comes to your comfort, no other holsters come close to what you get with the Ultimate belly band holster by the brand ComforTac.

Despite its small and lightweight profile, it can hold a wide range of pistols and handguns without any issue. It allows for multiple carry positions such as IWB, behind the hip, shoulder, appendix, etc. Its compact and lightweight design is a blessing to people who do not want to sacrifice comfort for security.

The unit comes with two variants; one for right-handed people and the other for the lefties. So before committing to a unit, make sure you get the one that suits your needs. In addition, it includes a trigger guard to further enhance the safety and security of your holstered weapon.

The built-in metal snap allows you to perfectly adjust the retention level according to your specification. It features a high-quality neoprene construction. You can adjust the size of the unit to get a comfortable fit without any hassle. In addition to the holster, it comes with an extra pocket to hold additional ammunition.

Pros :

  • Available for both lefties and righties
  • Extremely lightweight and comfortable
  • Affordable price tag
  • Comes with an additional pouch for an extra magazine


  • Re-holstering your weapon might be a bit difficult

4. Relentless Tactical The Defender Leather IWB Holster

Coming up next, we have an IWB holster that is aimed towards those on a tight budget. The Defender by the brand Relentless Tactical, brings all the excellent features and utility that you might want out of your gun holsters at a very reasonable price.

It is compatible with almost any 1911 style handguns you can find on the market. Thanks to the open mouth of the unit, the barrel length of the weapon is no longer an issue. Whether you go with Browning, Ruger, Taurus, or even Sig Sauer, you do not need to worry about whether the gun will fit the holster.

The unit comes with a strong and high-quality metal clip that goes into your belt loop for an easy and comfortable fit. It has a very low profile, which means that it leaves virtually no printing. Additionally, the overall design of the holster is smooth, ensuring that it will never interfere with your draw.

 Leather has always been an excellent choice of material when it comes to IWB holsters. Because of its smooth texture, the unit feels great even on bare skin. Besides comfort, it is also extremely durable. This unit has the potential to be your go-to holsters for a long time without showing any signs of wearing.

Pros :

  • High-quality leather construction
  • Compatible with gun barrels of any size
  • Comfortable and durable design
  • Comes in three stylish color options


  • Requires some breaking in to feel comfortable

5. Blade-Tech Industries Phantom Inside The Waistband Holster

If you still want to stick to IWB holsters for your 1911, the Phantom by the brand Blade-Tech Industries might be worth your attention. It is a super lightweight and minimalistic unit that emphasizes on the concealment of your firearm. In addition, it comes at a highly attractive price, making it affordable for just about anyone.

Its open-ended design allows you to fit any 1911 style handguns with a barrel of up to 5 inches without any trouble. By adjusting the screws on the side of the barrel-end of the holster, you can set the retention in the unit. It allows you to perfectly set up the tightness with little to no effort.

The unit comes with two belt loops to set it up with your belt. It uses “pull the dot” style snaps that do not require any additional force to open. There are both right and left-handed models available on the market, so make sure you choose the one that suits your hand preference.

This holster is constructed using thin .080 polymer that makes it extremely lightweight. Despite the low-profile design, the unit is quite durable and can take a beating. It also comes with a built-in sweat guard to ensure the safety of your firearms. Overall, it is a fantastic investment for people looking to buy the best 1911 concealed carry holster.

Pros :

  • It does not collapse when you pull out your gun.
  • Lightweight and compact design
  • Can fit weapons of 5-inch barrel length
  • Comes for both righties and lefties


  • The straps do not feel great

6. GalcoGunleather CM212 Combat Master Belt Holster

Nearing the end of our list, we are looking at a high-quality gun holster by the brand Galco. It is the only OWB gun holster on our list. Despite being an OWB holster, it conceals incredibly well thanks to its pancake design. And adding that with the exquisite leather construction, it is truly a product for the champs.

The unit has a butt-forward cant that helps you get quick and easy access to your gun. Despite not having any cant adjustment options, the preset design is enough to accommodate the needs of any user from a gun enthusiast to law enforcement officials. Apart from that, the detailed molding of the unit also ensures the perfect retention for your handgun.

 Its belt loop can fit belts of up to 1 ¾ inch thickness with no issues. The low-profile, slim design of the product can easily hide under the overhang of your shirt or under a jacket without leaving any visual printing. However, if you are wearing tight shirts, concealment might be difficult to achieve.

 The best quality of the unit is its leather finish. To further enhance its durability, all the pressure points of the holster come with double-stitched seams. It features a beautiful tan finish that looks gorgeous and feels premium despite its affordable price. If you want a budget holster for your 1911, it is one of the finest options out there.

Pros :

  • High quality leather construction
  • Affordable price tag
  • Quick and easy access to the handgun
  • Butt forward design


  • Does not allow for retention adjustment

7. BLACKHAWK Serpa Sportster Holster

The final product on our list of reviews is another excellent unit by the brand BLACKHAWK. Although we have already mentioned another product by this brand on the list, the unique features of the Sportster cannot be ignored. It has plenty of nifty designs that deserve a separate mention on our reviews.

Firstly the unit comes with an easily accessible retention adjustment screw that you can tighten or loosen to set it according to your specification. It is extremely simple and quick to get the perfect retention just by using a Philips head screwdriver. With your purchase, you get the paddle platform to quickly set it up.

This product features the same Serpa auto-lock technology that makes the brand so special. Holstering your weapon lets out a satisfactory click to let you know that the gun is locked and secured. It is extremely efficient and ensures complete safety for your handgun.

 The build quality of the unit is truly exceptional, and it can survive in any condition without any signs of wearing. It comes in a Gunmetal Gray finish that is extremely attractive. The model is available for both left and right-handed users and can fit a wide range of handguns and full-sized pistols, including 1911.

Pros :

  • Uses the Serpa Auto-lock technology
  • Easily adjustable passive retention system
  • Stylish and durable design
  • Affordable price tag


  • Does not allow for cant adjustment

Why Do You Need the A 1911 Holster?

Owning a gun and carrying it with you are two different things. If you are a collector, then the chances are that you have a safe at home to safely store your firearms. You are never worried about getting into a high-stress situation and simply keep your firearms as a collector’s piece.

While there is nothing wrong with that, some people prefer to use their weapons for self-defense. If you are one of them, a quality holster is a must-have for you. Without an excellent gun holster, you will not be able to carry your firearms with you efficiently.

1911-type handguns are typically on the heavy side. These are full-sized weapons with a solid steel body that requires a lot of maintenance. Part of keeping it operational at all times is carrying it the right way in the right holster. With the wrong holster, you will not be able to reach your gun easily when you need to.

In fact, the right holster can make all the difference when you get into a real-life firefight situation. Your draw speed, access to the gun, and your reflex will all be impacted by the holster. Sticking with a generic holster might be economical, but in most cases, it is not very practical.

Things to Consider When Buying the Best 1911 Holster

Regardless of the gun you own, the holster is an important thing. When choosing the best holster for 1911, you need to be extra careful in determining whether your gun will fit it or not.

 Besides that, there are many small factors that you need to consider when choosing your holster like its overall design or retention. With that said, here are a few things that you should consider when buying the best holster for 1911


When looking for a 1911 holster, one of the first things that you need to decide is whether you want an IWB holster or an OWB one. IWB holster or inside the waist band holsters are the ones you want for concealed carry. Outside the waist band or OWB holsters are only suitable for people with open carry licenses.

If you are a general gun owner, then IWB holsters would be your only choice in most cases. Although these units do not have amazing draw speed, they are enough for most situations you will face in real life. And generally speaking, you should keep your weapon out of sight as a responsible gun owner.

OWB holsters are better suited for law enforcement or government official. Since 1911 type handguns are generally issued by the government, an OWB holster is also a good option to carry this weapon. This type of holster is also typically more comfortable and allows for faster draw speed.

In our list of reviews, we mostly focused on IWB holsters so that most people can buy one without any restrictions. If you want the best 1911 IWB holster, our list of reviews already spotlights some of the best ones on the market. And as long as you are careful with your purchase, you do not have to compromise on the comfort and draw speed too much.

Retention Adjustment Capabilities

You also need to consider the retention of the holster before you invest your hard-earned money on it. Retention is an important element of any gun holster. It refers to the strength with which the holster grips your gun when you place your weapon inside it.

It is extremely important that your holster comes with comfortable retention that allows you to yank out your handgun without exerting any additional force. However, if the retention is too weak, your gun can simply slip or fall off when you are walking. In the worst-case scenario, a person can snatch your weapon from your holster if the retention is not set properly.

Thankfully, most gun holsters give you some room of adjustment to help you modify the retention strength. It is usually in the form of screws on the side of the holster that you can tighten or loosen to get the proper settings. If your unit allows you to adjust the retention, you should spend some time trying to set it up perfectly.

However, not all models give you this option. In case your unit does not have any retention adjustment options, you need to check and test out the holster yourself before buying it. Although retention is a simple thing, overlooking this factor can bring a world of trouble for you.


Just because you are buying an OWB holster does not mean it has to be fully concealed to the world. Concealment, in the case of firearms, implies that your handgun or pistol will stay out of sight as much as possible. A concealed firearm will stick close to your body and will not draw any extra attention to itself.

With IWB holsters, concealment is a no brainer. That is the primary function of this type of holster. So when you are buying this type of gun holsters, make sure there is no printing under your clothes, the gun sticks close to your body, and it does not poke out through the buttons in your shirt.

For OWB holsters, it is not as simple. Since this type of holsters stays outside your body, concealing them can be difficult. You could try wearing a long overcoat that can go over the guns to hide it. Additionally, you should go for a low-profile unit so that you can keep your gun as discreet as realistically possible.

Material Selection

The material with which the holster is made tells you a lot about the product. Whether it will be comfortable to wear, the overall durability of the product, how long you can wear it without any issues, these are some of the factors that you can understand just by looking at the material alone.

When it comes to gun holsters, the two most common materials in use are leather or some form of the polymer.

Leather holsters are an excellent choice because of its unprecedented durability and comfort. It is a soft material that feels great on the skin, and it can take a lot of beating without showing any signs of abuse. However, leather holsters can sometimes feel stiff when you first buy it and may require some breaking in.

But eventually, a leather holster will deform regardless of the quality of the material. If you want a lifetime of usage, you can look into holsters made of polymers like Kydex, or Bolatron. These materials are not as soft as leather but can resist damage to a greater degree.

You can also find products made of softer polymers such as nylon, especially in the affordable price range. In general, nylon is not a great candidate when it comes to 1911-type handguns. These handguns are heavy, and the soft nature of nylon can get damaged quite easily, trying to support its weight.

Weapon Compatibility

Despite being such a simple factor, you would be surprised as to how many people overlook the size of the unit before buying it. If the holster that you buy does not fit your handgun, then there is no point buying it. Since 1911 type handguns have a very distinct structure, you need to carefully check the design of the holster to see if it can accommodate the weapon.

A handgun holster can be sewn or molded from plastic materials. Regardless of how it is made, the size is a crucial factor to consider. Some holsters come with generic holders that can fit a wide range of handguns. Although they are a good option, you need to remember that there is no such thing as universal when it comes to this type of product.

When buying your holster for 1911, you should typically find a list of compatible weapons in its specifications chart. It would be a good idea to go through the list and check if your weapon is present in it. If yes, then you can buy it without a second thought. However, if your weapon is not listed, you need to look elsewhere.

Cant Adjustment Options

Cant is also another important factor when it comes to gun holsters. It refers to the angle at which your pistol rests when you put it inside the holster. Depending on the cant angle, you will have a superior draw speed, or you will have to fiddle around with your weapon wasting precious seconds to take out your weapon.

Any good holster will give you the option to adjust the cant angle. Since there is no perfect drawing angle for your firearm, you need to adjust the angle testing out different positions until you can settle on your preferred position. Without this option, you will be stuck with a single drawing angle, which is never a good thing.

You can never hope to achieve a smooth draw without properly setting up the cant angle in the holster. For people who want to appendix carry, a vertical draw angle might be a good place to start adjustments. For hip carriers, somewhere between 15 to 20 degrees will be the sweet spot.

Frequently Asked Questions 

What is the best position to carry my holster for 1911?

There is no definitive carry position that suits everyone when it comes to gun holsters. Some people might find the appendix to be the superior position for an easier draw, while some might be more comfortable drawing from the hip. It ultimately comes down to the preference and comfort of the user.

Is it illegal to use OWB holsters for 1911?

It typically varies from one state to another. To understand whether you can legally carry a weapon in your OWB holster in public, you need to understand the gun laws in your particular state. Some states allow you to open-carry a firearm while some states are very restrictive in this regard.

So before you decide to buy an OWB holster to open-carry your weapon, it is a good idea to check the gun laws of your state.

Is it safe to carry 1911 in a holster?

As long as you follow all the gun safety rules, there should not be any safety issues when carrying a holstered weapon regardless of its type. One thing you can do to improve the safety of the holster is to buy a unit that comes with a built-in trigger guard.

A trigger guard is basically a small section that covers the trigger of your weapon when it is holstered, essentially blocking your access to the trigger. This ensures that you will not be able to pull the trigger of the holstered weapon accidentally when pulling out your gun.

 Even if your holster does not come with this feature, you can buy an aftermarket trigger guard. If you do not want to spend any extra money on this, you can even craft one yourself out of plastic or leather quite easily.

Final Thoughts

The quality of the gun is definitely an important factor. But without the right holster, the overall performance you get from the weapon is reduced drastically. If you are a proud owner of a 1911-type handgun, your next order of business should be to buy the best 1911 holster to carry it.

Our list of reviews should give you plenty of options, making the selection process a lot easier for you. We hope our extensive product review and buying tips could help you find the right product with minimal hassle and headache.

Last Updated on November 22, 2020 by Ronald K. Smith

Leave a Comment

Scroll to Top